Files
Obsidian/X-Articles/5 levels of AI marketing (and how to master each one).md
2026-07-21 14:53:24 +08:00

176 lines
11 KiB
Markdown
Raw Permalink Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters
This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.
---
title: "5 levels of AI marketing (and how to master each one)"
source: "https://x.com/shannholmberg/status/2033596949601865786"
author:
- "[[@shannholmberg]]"
published: 2026-03-15
created: 2026-04-26
description: "karpathy scored 342 US jobs AI exposure. marketing scored a 9 out of 10.That means everyone in marketing are cooked, but only IF they don´t ..."
tags:
- "clippings"
---
![图像](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/HDiguWcakAAqRo6?format=jpg&name=large)
karpathy scored 342 US jobs AI exposure. marketing scored a 9 out of 10.
That means everyone in marketing are cooked, but only IF they don´t take action now.
and yet, most people using AI for marketing are still copy-pasting ChatGPT outputs that sound like your average washed up LinkedIn influencer.
```text
LEVEL WHAT IT IS
─────────────────────────────────────────
1 custom prompts
2 manual skills
3 skills + brand foundation
4 agents with skills
5 autonomous agent teams
─────────────────────────────────────────
```
I built a multi-agent content system over the past few months. not as a side project, as the actual production workflow for my agency. during that process I realized there are five distinct levels to how people use AI for marketing, and almost everyone is stuck at level 1 or 2.
I will walk you through each level because understanding where you are right now is the fastest way to figure out what to do next.
## level 1: custom prompts
![图像](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/HDiWeWtWMAAy31Z?format=jpg&name=large)
this is where 90% of people start and where most of them stay forever.
you open ChatGPT. you type "write me an email for my product launch." you get something back that sounds vaguely professional but could have been written for literally any product on earth.
every session starts from zero, with no memory of your brand, no context about your audience and no knowledge of what worked last time. you are starting a new relationship with a stranger every time you sit down to write.
**the output at this level is generic because the input is generic.** one line of instruction produces one dimension of output.
if this is you right now, thats fine. everyone starts here. but staying here is expensive in ways you dont realize yet.
## level 2: manual skills
![图像](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/HDjCW9UbwAAjPsl?format=jpg&name=large)
level 2 is where most "AI-savvy" marketers land. instead of one-line prompts, you build detailed prompt templates packed with frameworks.
think Schwartz awareness levels baked into your email sequences. proof stacking patterns for landing pages. specific CTA structures tested across hundreds of campaigns.
a skill at this level is 1,200+ lines of structured framework. Compare that to a simple prompt, the difference in output quality is night and day.
but you are still running everything manually. every time you want to create something, you open the skill, paste your inputs, run it, and review the output. it´s better than level 1 by a mile, but it still requires you to be the engine.
**the ceiling here is your time.** you can produce great individual pieces, but you can´t scale because every piece still needs your hands on the keyboard.
## level 3: skills plus a brand foundation
![图像](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/HDjCcBgXoAAP-FL?format=jpg&name=large)
truth is, this is where most people should be spending their time right now. almost nobody is.
you create a brand foundation file with your voice, your tone, the words you always use. the words you never use. your audience's pain points. your positioning against competitors. the phrases that sound like you versus the phrases that sound like AI slop.
then your skills reference this foundation automatically. every output passes through your brand filter before it reaches you.
at level 2, you might produce a great email but it doesnt sound like you. at level 3, everything sounds like you because the system knows who "you" is.
**one foundation feeds all your skills.** email skill, social media skill, landing page skill, ad copy skill. they all pull from the same source of truth. consistency across every channel without you manually enforcing it.
this is where your AI content starts scaring your competitors. because it doesnt read as AI anymore. it reads as you, moving at 10x speed.
## level 4: agents with skills
![图像](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/HDjCg7paoAAsZwm?format=jpg&name=large)
most marketers have never touched this level, and honestly, six months ago neither had I.
an agent reads your goal, plans the steps, selects the right skills, and executes. one command triggers a full workflow.
at my agency, I can say "research the top 20 tweets about AI marketing this week, generate 5 content ideas based on what performed, and draft the best one" and the system does it. research agent pulls the data. idea agent structures the concepts. writer agent produces the draft. critic agent scores it before I ever see it.
the key concept at this level is subagents. these are isolated specialists that run in parallel. the parent agent delegates a task, the subagent executes in isolation, and returns only the distilled results.
> 3月15日
as [@akshay\_pachaar](https://x.com/@akshay_pachaar) put it in his article: "subagents are for decomposition." they break a big task into smaller independent pieces. research, writing, editing as separate isolated tasks, fire-and-forget parallelism.
**one person doing the work of a small team.** the coordination cost drops to zero because you dont need to brief anyone, wait for deliverables, or manage handoffs. the agents just run.
## level 5: autonomous agent teams
![图像](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/HDjCnCUWMAA3tSw?format=jpg&name=large)
very few people are here yet. this is the endgame.
the difference between level 4 and level 5 is coordination. at level 4, subagents work in isolation. at level 5, agents share context, build on each others outputs, and compound their knowledge over time.
**agent teams are for coordination.** a team orchestrator reads a shared briefing, distributes tasks, and agents build on each others work. the research agent's findings feed directly into the writer's context. the critic's feedback loops back into the next draft cycle.
and then there is memory.
run 1 of your system produces a brand voice document and a first draft. run 5 adds performance data and tighter headlines based on what actually got clicks. run 20 has audience feedback baked in, personalized patterns for different segments, and a track record of what converted versus what bounced.
the system gets better every time it runs. it learns from engagement data. it adapts to what your audience actually responds to instead of what you think they respond to.
I know of an 8-person team running 38 agents across 8 departments right now. content, SEO, paid ads, email, social, analytics, CRM, reporting. each department has its own agent cluster, and they all share context through a central knowledge base.
at this level, AI marketing is infrastructure. Not a tool you open its more like an OS you run.
but there is a catch.
## why most people wont do this
AI-generated ads show a 19% improvement in clickthrough rates. but purchase likelihood drops 33% when consumers know AI created the content.
"AI slop" mentions went from 461K to 2.4M in a single year, thats a 5x increase in people calling out bad AI content.
the gap between levels 1-2 and levels 3-5 is taste, judgement & technical skills. the people at levels 1-2 are producing volume. the people at levels 3-5 are producing volume that doesn´t read as AI because they baked their judgment into the system.
Rick Rubin doesnt play instruments on most of the albums he produces. but every album sounds intentional because his taste shapes every decision. thats the model. you are not the one writing anymore. you are the one deciding what stays, what gets cut, and what gets refined.
**the moat is taste.** anyone can set up agents, the hard part is having judgment worth adding to them.
karpathy scored 342 US jobs on a 0-10 AI exposure scale. market researchers scored a 9. writers and editors scored a 9. graphic designers scored a 9. marketing is one of the most exposed professions on the entire list.
The jobs growing are the ones that require judgment at levels 3-5.
## your first moves at each level
**level 1 to level 2:** write three detailed prompt templates for your most common marketing tasks. email sequences, social posts, ad copy. include your frameworks, your constraints, examples of good output. go from a 1-line prompt to a 50-line skill document.
**level 2 to level 3:** spend two hours writing your brand foundation. voice, tone, audience, positioning, words you never say. then make every skill reference it. this single file will improve every piece of content your AI produces.
**level 3 to level 4:** pick one workflow you do repeatedly and automate it end-to-end. for me it was the research-to-draft pipeline. identify the steps, build a skill for each one, then connect them through an agent that orchestrates the sequence.
**level 4 to level 5:** add memory. start logging what performs and what doesnt. feed that data back into your agents. build a shared context layer that all your agents can read from.
## the cost
```text
TRANSITION TIME EFFORT
─────────────────────────────────────────────────
1 → 2 an afternoon write 3 detailed prompt templates
2 → 3 a weekend build your brand foundation doc
3 → 4 1-2 weeks automate one full workflow
4 → 5 ongoing compounds every month
─────────────────────────────────────────────────
ROI: exponential. levels 3-5 pay back daily.
```
level 1 to 2 takes an afternoon. maybe 3-4 hours of writing detailed prompts.
level 2 to 3 takes a weekend. the brand foundation document is the hard part because it forces you to articulate things about your voice that you have never written down.
level 3 to 4 takes 1-2 weeks of building and testing, depending on how complex your workflow is.
level 4 to 5 is ongoing. the system compounds over months. this is not a project you finish, its an infrastructure you maintain.
**the ROI curve is exponential though**. the time you invest at levels 3-5 pays back every day after that. your system runs while you sleep, and it compounds what it learned from last week into this weeks output.
## the window
right now, operating at level 3 or above puts you in a tiny minority. most agencies and most marketers are still at level 1, maybe level 2. the ones who build their systems now will have compounding advantages that late adopters cant catch up to.
because the advantage isn´t just speed, but accumulated taste, judgment, and months of memory that a competitor starting from scratch doesn´t have.
every week you wait is a week of compounding you don´t get back.
I´ve been documenting exactly how I built my systems from level 1 through level 5. if this was useful, save this, drop a like and follow along. im breaking down each level in detail over the coming weeks.